Wednesday, March 27, 2013

Time to regulate surrogacy in India | Culture |

Time to regulate surrogacy in India | Culture | - Source

Time to regulate surrogacy in India

   By  Devadatt Kamat and Lavanya Regunath
27 Mar 2013

Surrogacy in India continues to remain a very sensitive topic. The laws meant to regulate surrogacy are still in nascent stages, as they are stuck at various legislative levels.
The only guidelines currently related to this field are those of the Indian Medical Association (IMA), which date back to 2006.
A still from the documentary, Made In India, which explores reproductive technology (Courtesy: Made In India)
Meanwhile, surrogacy is growing rapidly by the day, thanks to India emerging as a centre for medical tourism and being one of the few countries in the world where commercial surrogacy is widely available. Estimates for the value of this industry range from Rs 20 billion to 2.3 billion US dollars.
The legal situation in India is in sharp contrast to that existing in many other countries. In Germany and Canada surrogacy is outlawed or prohibited, in the United Kingdom it is highly regulated and very expensive.
In Germany, over the last three years, there have been two controversial cases. The first, in 2008, involved twins born to a surrogate mother; the second arose barely a year ago. In both cases, German authorities refused to automatically give passports to children born of surrogate procedures.
In both instances, the surrogacy procedure had been carried out in India. The main reason for the refusal of visas for these children was because surrogacy is not allowed in Germany. This is a homogenous and consistent line of reasoning and is very much in contradiction to the state of affairs in India where at the moment this sector is almost completely unregulated.
There are references in Indian mythology to surrogacy, most notably in the legend surrounding Lord Krishna. But it is not commercial surrogacy – the type and scale of which is practiced in India.
Today, the small Gujarat town of Anand, well known for it’s butter – another motif from the tales relating to Lord Krishna – has rapidly put itself on the global map as the most fertile ground for ‘surrogacy tourism’. All evidence suggests that the phenomenon has now spread from cities to smaller towns in India, with many of the centres calling themselves in vitro fertilisation (IVF) clinics to avoid public scrutiny.
Of course, there is not much emphasis given to the setting up of norms to govern this growing industry. The IMA guidelines are more like normative principles that are required to be followed and not statutory instruments that invite penalties.
At present, in India the understanding between the surrogate mother and the commissioning parents is considered a contract, with a mention made of compensation to be paid to the mother. So although the guidelines recognise the existence of commercial surrogacy, it is relegated to the realm of an ordinary business contract. In other words, jurisprudence developed for commerce along with  medical guidelines are the only form of regulation of a business that is referred to - and one can only assume without irony – ‘as wombs for rent’.
The Law Commission of India has brought out a report on surrogacy and the urgent need for regulation entitled, ‘Need for Legislation to Regulate Assisted Reproductive Technology Clinics as well as Rights and Obligations of Parties to a Surrogacy’.
Unfortunately, this report, too, is now over three years old and the draft legislation on the issue, termed the ‘The Assisted Reproductive Technologies (Regulation) Bill 2010’, is still nowhere in sight as a legally enforceable statute.
The draft Bill itself is not without contentious issues since it is drafted from the perspective of the commissioning parents. The methods of payment to the surrogate and the other arrangements it lays down seem to suggest quite clearly that the surrogate figures low in the list of priorities in terms of care and protection.
This is disturbing considering that surrogacy raises several ethical considerations including the fact that it leaves poor women at the mercy of a capricious system. These women often have no other recourse other than commercial surrogacy arrangements to buy themselves and their families out of debilitating circumstances.
SAMA, a resource group working in the area of women and health, has raised concerns regarding the current situation as well as serious problems with the Bill. The number of pregnancies, the types of procedures and the care of the surrogate are all matters that have been inadequately addressed, both by the medical system as it exists today and the Bill.
There is also the issue of race and the ethics to be considered. The implications of the use of a ‘cheaper’ womb for children to be born from eggs and sperm donated by persons, usually of Caucasian descent requires to be considered.
The Law Commission Report very succinctly puts down the issue facing India today when it says that the “non-intervention of law in this knotty issue will not be proper at a time when law is to act as ardent defender of human liberty and an instrument of distribution of positive entitlements.
“At the same time, prohibition on vague moral grounds without a proper assessment of social ends and purposes which surrogacy can serve would be irrational.
“Active legislative intervention is required to facilitate correct uses of the new technology i.e., ART, and relinquish the cocooned approach to legalisation of surrogacy adopted hitherto. The need of the hour is to adopt a pragmatic approach by legalising altruistic surrogacy arrangements and prohibit commercial ones.”
In addition, it is pertinent to note that there is hardly the required encouragement to look at adoption as a viable alternative to surrogacy to parents willing to consider this as an option to add to their family. Till recently adoption procedures in India were cumbersome and based purely on religious affiliation.
With the coming into being of the CARA, or the Central Resource Adoption Agency, though this position has eased somewhat and adoption can now be a secular process. Nevertheless, the process suffers from delays and does not always provide the confidence to couples that it might be a viable method to add to the family.
The Supreme Court of India, in the 2008 case of Baby Manji Yamada v/s Union of India discussed surrogacy and noted that commercial surrogacy is reaching industrial proportions because of the ready availability of poor surrogates. It mentioned the 2005 Commissions For Protection of Child Rights Act but stopped short of demanding that the government take immediate action to regulate the whole surrogacy industry, and not just address the issue of the rights of the child once it is born.
But while civil society groups, the media, the courts and the Law Commission have periodically focused on the various negative aspects of the ART industry, the apathy of the country’s own legislators makes one wonder what is required to spur them to address the serious ethical and moral dimensions of this unregulated enterprise.
There is no need to ban outright all surrogate procedures. India’s history of tolerance and the primacy of the family mean procedures like this can exist in harmony with options like natural childbirth or adoption.
But the rampant commercialisation and lack of regulation that marks the use of ART in India create a shameful legacy for a procedure meant to bring joy to a family.
-  Women's Feature Service


sath roian said...

NICE BLOG!!! Thanks for sharing useful information about Touraeas and being one of best Tourism Website agree that this blog is very useful for the Tourism are Searching for best tourist Places , I would really like to come back again right here for likewise good articles or blog posts. Thanks for sharing...Tour places in India.

Sankar Kumar said...

Surrogacy is the arrangement by which a woman conceives, carries and delivers a child for another couple or individual. This woman is known as a surrogate mother or a gestational carrier. If you are thinking to go INDIA for IVF surrogacy, then you must search for Surrogacy India, Surrogate mother India, IVF India, IVF clinic India & IVF cost india. I found Go Surrogacy for this treatment in India. Hope you also like these.

progenyivfsurrogacy said...

Fertility treatments have come up as a hope many couples. They have helped a lot number of people in bringing their bundle of joy in this world and attain motherhood. Though, it is said that not all fertility treatments are suitable for women who are trying to conceive. Treatments of fertility mainly depend on the cause, age, for how long one has been infertile and many other personal preferences.

progenyivfsurrogacy said...

Embryo donation is seen as an alternative route to pregnancy. It helps couples that would otherwise be unable to conceive, carry a pregnancy to term. A relatively new procedure, embryo donation involves using another couple's embryos in order to conceive. These donated embryos are then transferred into your uterus using frozen embryo transfer...

Best Infertility Treatment in India

Embryo Donation India

Kiran IVF said...

Doctors at Kiran Infertility Centre that gets around 120 foreign nationals for Surrogacy India say the move will be a drain on the economy.Dr Samit Sekhar, chief embryologist and surrogacy and IVF program director, said that as per the new directive, except a foreign "man and woman" who have been married for a period of at least two years, no one else will be eligible to have an Indian surrogate bear their child.