Pages

Monday, June 9, 2014

Karnataka HC Order in MFA filed u/s 54(1) of LAQAct against Kumta Civil Judge Sr Divn Order in LAC no.234-2006

http://indiankanoon.org/doc/92775804/

Karnataka High Court
The Spl. Land Acquisition ... vs Ganu Pattu Padti, on 3 July, 2012
Author: Ram Mohan Reddy
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA CIRCUIT BENCH AT DHARWAD

DATED THIS THE 3RD DAY OFJULY, 2012

BEFORE

THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE RAM MOHAN REDDY

M.F.A. NO. 24194/2011 (LAC) A/W.

M.F.A. Nos. 24195/2011, 24310/2011, 24407/2011, 24460/2011, 24479/2011, 24648/2011, 24661/2011, 24669/2011, 24906/2011, 24907/2011, 25399/2011, 25442/2011, 25484/2011, 25490/2011, 25591/2011, 25719/2011, 20367/2012, 20386/20 12. 20390/2012. 20412/2012. 20413/2012, 2O566/2012, 20569/2012, 2 1219/2012, 22376/2012, 22430/2012, 22431/2012, 22462/2012 & 22889/2009

IN M.F.A. NO. 24194/2011:

BETWEEN

THE SPL. LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, PROJECT SEA BIRD,

NAVAL BASE, KARWAR,

.APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.)

AND

1. GANU PATTU PADTI, SINCE DECEASED BY LRS. 1A. SMT. TAHKI W/O GANU PADI, AGE: 50 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURE & HOUSEHOLD, R/O MELINAKERI, NEAR GANAPATI TEMPLE, MUDGA, AMADALLI, TQ. KARWAR.

lB. SMT, SEETA ( BEJARI W/O UDAY NAGEKAR,

AGE: 27 YEARS,

0CC: HOUSEHOLD,

R/O C/0 UDAY MAHABALESHWAR NAGEKAR, BAGINKATTA, TQ. YELLAPUR.

1C. SANTOSH 5/0 GANU PADI AGE: 25 YEARS,

NEAR GANAPATI TEMPLE, MUDGA, AMADALLI, TQ. KARWAR.

1D. KUMARI ASHA D/0 GANU ADTI, AGE: 23 YEARS, 0CC: HOUSEHODL, R/O NEAR GANAPATI TEMPLE, MUDGA, AMADALLI, TQ. KARWAR.

2. KHEMU PUTI'U PADTI, SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.

PARVATI W/0 KHEMU PADTI, SINCE DECEASED BY HER LRS.

2A. SMT, MANGALA

W/0 GURUNATH PADTI KANKONAKAR, AGE: 32 YEARS, CCC: HOUSEHOLD, R/0 MUDGA, AMADALLI, TQ. KARWAR.

2B. PREMA D/OKHEMU PADTI AGE: 28 YEARS,

0CC: HOUSEHOLD,

R/0 MUDGA, AMADALLI, 3

TQ. KARWAR.

2C. MURU LIDHAR S/O KHEMU PADTI AGE: 19 YEARS,

R/O MUDGA, AMADALLI, TQ. KARWAR.

RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.54(1) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894, AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DTD:22.12.2006, PASSED IN LAC NO.186/1994, ON THE FILE OF THE ADDL. CIVIL JUDGE[SR.DN.j, KARWAR, AWARDING COMPENSATION OF RS.11,500/- PER GUNTA.

IN M.F.A. NO. 24195/2011:

BETWEEN

THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, PROJECT SEA BIRD, NAVAL BASE, KARWAR.

APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.)

AND

HUVA @ VENKATESH RAMA NAYAK, SINCE DECEASED BY LRS.

1. SUBBI W/O HUVA@VENKATESH RAMA NAYAK, AGE: 70 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURIST.

2. RAMADAS S/O HUVA VENKATESH RAMA NAYAK, AGE: 45 YEARS,

0CC: AGRICULTURIST.

3. GOVINDS/OHUVA

4

@ VENKATESH RAMA NAYAK, AGE: 40 YEARS, 0CC: TEACHER.

Ri TO R3 ARE R/O. BHAVIKERI, TQ. ANKOLA.

4. DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER, KARNATAKA & OOA CIRCLE, BANGALORE--42.

RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.54(1) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894, AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DTD:24.10.2008, PASSED IN LAC NO.246/2006, ON THE FILE OF THE CIVIL JUDGE (SR.DN.), KUMTA, AWARDING COMPENSATION OF RS.11,500/- PER GUNTA.

IN M.F,A. NO. 24310/2011:

BETWEEN

THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, PROJECT SEA BIRD, NAVAL BASE, KARWAR. DIST: KARWAR, APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.)

AND

VENKATARAY RAMA NAYAK, SINCE DECEASED BY HIS L.R.S,

1. SMT. RAJANI W/O. VENKATARAY NAYAK, AGE: ABOUT 55 YEARS, 0CC: HOUSEHOLD, R/O: BHAVIKERT, TQ: ANKOLA, DIST: KARWAR.

2. SOMA VENKATARAY NAYAK, AGE: ABOUT 31 YEARS, 0CC: PVT., SERVICE,

R/0: BHAVIKERI, TQ: ANKOLA, DIST: KARWAR.

3. RAJESH VENKATARAY NAYAK, AGE: ABOUT 30 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURIST,

R/O: BHAVIKERI, TQ: ANKOLA, DIST: KARWAR.

4. VANI D/0. VENKATARAY NAYAK, AGE: ABOUT 27 YEARS, 0CC: HOUSEHOLD, R/O: BHAVJKERI, TQ: ANKOLA, DIST: KARWAR.

5. HANAMU KOM KALLU NAYAK, R/0: BHAVIKERI, TQ: ANKOLA, DIST: KARWAR,

6. SHARADA KOM. GOVIND NAYAK, R/O: BHAVIKERI, TQ: ANKOLA, DIST: KARWAR.

7. GIRIYAMMA KOM. NEELKANTH NAYAK, R/O: BHAVIKERI, TQ: ANKOLA, DIST: KARWAR.

8. DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER, KARNATAKA & GOA CIRCLE, BANGALORE-42,

RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.54(1) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894, AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DTD:22.12,2009, PASSED IN LAC NO.172/2006, ON THE FILE OF THE CIVIL JUDGE [SR.DN.1. KUMTA, AWARDING COMPENSATION OF RS. 11,500/ PER GUNTA. -

6

IN M.F.A. NO.24407/2011:

BETWEEN

THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, PROJECT SEA BIRD, NAVAL BASE, KARWAR.

APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.) AND

SRI. GIDIYA HEDDU GOUDA, SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.

1. SRI. BHANU GIDIYA GIRIYA @ LINGA GOUDA

R/O TODUR, PALEKARWADA, KARWAR.

2. SMT. SAVITRI W/O SESHU GOUDA 0CC: HOUSEHOLD,

R/O HARWADA, TQ. ANKOLA.

3. SMT. TIMMI W/O VENKA GOUDA 0CC: HOUSEHOLD,

R/O TODUR, PALEKARWADA, TQ. KARWAR.

2. SMT. LEKHI W/O ROHIDAS GOUDA, 0CC: HOUSEHOLD,

R/O IRAGI, MALLAPUR, TQ. KARWAR.

3. SMT. LEELA W/O SANTOSH GOUDA, CCC: HOUSEHOLD,

R/O PALEKARWADA, TODUR, TQ. KARWAR.

4. SRI. DURGADAS S/O GIDIYA 7

@ GIRIYA LINGA GOUDA, 0CC: COOLIE,

R/O PALEKARWADA, TODUR, TQ. KARWAR.

5. THE DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER, KARNATAKA GOA CIRCLE, BANGALORE. ... RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.54(1) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894, AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DTD:25.02.2009, PASSED IN LAC NO.41/2006, ON THE FILE OF THE ADD. CIVIL JUDGE (SR.DN.) KARWAR, AWARDING COMPENSATION OF RS.17,800/- PER GUNTA.

IN M.F.A. NO.24460/2011:

BETWEEN

THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, PROJECT SEA BIRD, NAVAL BASE, KARWAR. ... APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.)

AND

1. HANUMANT NARAYANA ACHARI, AGE: 58 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURIST, R/O BHAVIKERI, TQ. ANKOLA, DIST. UTT'AR KANNADA.

2. DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER, KARNATAKA & GOA CIRCLE, BANGALORE-42. ... RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.54(1) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894, AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DTD:13.10.2009, PASSED IN LAC NO.195/2006, ON THE 8

FILE OF THE CIVIL JUDGE (SRDN.) KUMTA, AWARDING COMPENSATION OF RS. 11,500/- PER GUNTA.

IN M.F.A. NO24479/2011:

BETWEEN

THE SPL. LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, PROJECT SEA BIRD, NAVAL BASE, KARWAR. APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.) AND

I. SUSHILA W/O BOMMAYYA NAIK R/O BONUNAMANE,

R/O TOPPADAKERI,

BHAVIKERI, ANKOLA.

2. SANNAPPA S/O BEERAPPA NAYAK R/O BONUNAMANE,

R/O TOPPADAKERI,

BHAVIKERI, ANKOLA.

3. RAMACHANDRA BEERAPPA NAIK R/O BONUNAMANE,

R/O TOPPADAKERI,

BHAVIKERI, ANKOLA.

4. THE DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER KARNATAKA & GOA CIRCLE, BANGALORE-2.

RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.54(1) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894, AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DTD:29.02.2008, PASSED IN LAC NO.106/2006, ON THE FILE OF THE CIVIL JUDGE (SR.DN.) KUMTA, AWARDING COMPENSATION OF RS.11,500/- PER GUNTA. 9

IN M.F.A. NO.24648/2011:

BETWEEN

THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, SEA BIRD PROJECT, NAVAL EASE, KARWAR.

APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.)

AND

1. BANTA RAMA GOUDA R/O BADAGERI, BHAVIKATT'I, TQ. ANKOLA.

2. RAKU DEVU GOUDA SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LR.

2A. DEVU S/0 RAKU GOUDA, AGE: 60 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURE, R/O BADAGERI, ALAGERI, ANKOLA.

3. BUDDUDEVUGOUDA SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LR.

3A. SURESH BUDDU GOUDA, AGE: 30 YEARS,

0CC: AGRICULTURE,

R/O BADAGERI, ALAGERI, ANKOLA.

4. SHIVU SANKUSA GOUDA SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LR.

GANGA SANKUSA GOUDA

R/O BADAGERI, BHAVIKERI, ANKOLA. 10

5. TULASU,

REP. BY MINOR GUARDIAN NAGAMMA HEDDU GOUDA

R/O BADAGERI, BHAVIKERI, ANKOLA.

6. ASHAHEDDUGOUDA SINCE DECEASED BY HER LR,

6A. DEVAMMA W/O ASHA GOUDA AGE: 35 YEARS,

0CC: HOUSEHOLD WORK

R/O BADAGERI, BHAVIKERI, ANKOLA.

6B. BABU S/O ASHA GOUDA AGE: 17 YEARS, 0CC: STUDENT.

6C. PRADEEP S/O ASHA GOUDA AGE: 15 YEARS, 0CC: STUDENT.

6D. VISHWANATH S/O ASHA GOUDA AGE: 13 YEARS, 0CC: STUDENT.

R6(b) to R6(d) ARE MINORS, REP. BY THEIR NEXT FRIEND & GUARDIAN MOTHER

SMT. DEVAMMA W/0. LATE ASHA GOUDA.

ALL ARE R/0 BADAGERI, BHAVIKERI, ANKOLA.

7. THE DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER, SEA BIRD PROJECT, NAVAL BASE, KARWAR.

RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.54(1) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894, AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DTD:28.05.2009, PASSED IN LAC NO.191/2006, ON THE II

FILE OF THE CIVIL JUDGE (SR.DN.) KUMTA, AWARDING COMPENSATION OF RS.11,500/- PER GUNTA.

IN M.F.A. NO.24661/2011:

BETWEEN

THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER SEA BIRD PROJECT-TI, NAVAL BASE, KARWAR.

APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.)

AND

HAMMANNA CHIPA NAIK

SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LR

1. SMT. MAHADEVI W/O GANAPATI NAYAK AGE: 45 YEARS, 0CC: HOUSEHOLD WORK, R/O: BHAVIKERI, TQ: ANKOLA, DIST: KARWAR.

2. HOSABU CHIPA NAIK AGE: MAJOR, R/O: BHAVIKERI, TQ: ANKOLA, DIST: KARWAR.

3. THE DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER KARNATAKA GOA CIRCLE, BANGALORE.

RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.54(1) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894 AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DTD:30-08-2008, PASSED IN LAC NO.117/2006, ON THE FILE OF THE CIVIL JUDGE(SR.DN) KUMTA, AWARDING THE COMPENSATION OF RS.11,500/-PER GUNTA. 12

INt1RA,NO.24669/201

BETWEEN

THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, PROJECT, SEA BIRD, NAVAL BASE, KARWAR. ...APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A,)

AND

BHANU MADA GOWDA,

SINCE DECEASED BY HIS L.RS.

I. SOMI BHANU GOUDA, AGE: 65 YEARS,

R/O BHAJANKERI,

AMADALLI VILLAGE,

KARWAR TALUK.

2. SMT. OMI NINGA GOUDA, AGE: 49 YEARS,

R/O BHAJANKERI,

AMADALLI VILLAGE,

KARWAR TALUK.

3. GOVIND BHANU GOUDA, AGE: 45 YEARS,

R/O BHAJANKERI,

AMADALLI VILLAGE,

KARWAR TALUK.

4. SMT. VISHNU BHANU GOUDA, AGE: 39 YEARS,

R/O BHAJANKERI,

AMADALLI VILLAGE,

KARWAR TALUK.

13

5. DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER, KARNATAKA & GOA CIRCLE, BANGALORE-42.

RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.54(1) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894 AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DTD:28-08-2006, PASSED IN LAC NO.25/1993, ON THE FILE OF THE ADDL. CIVIL JUDGE(SR.DN) KARWAR, AWARDING THE COMPENSATION OF RS.1 1,500/-PER GUNTA.

IN M.F.A. NO.24906/2011:

BETWEEN

THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, SEA BIRD NAVAL BASE PROJECT, KARWAR.

APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.)

AND

1, TARA SIDU NAIK.

2. SRI. MITA RITA NAIK, SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.

SMT. RADHA MITA NAIK, AGE: 67 YEARS, R/O AMADALLI, TQ. KARWAR.

3. MEERA GANAPATI NAIK AGE: 47 YEARS,

R/O AMADALLI, TQ. KARWAR. Li

14

4. SUMA VISHNU NAIK AGE: 41 YEARS,

R/O AMADALLI, TQ. KARWAR,

5. SMT. GRIPA GANGADHAR NAIK AGE: 34 YEARS,

R/O AMADALLI, TQ. KARWAR.

6. SMT. DEEPA DATTA NAIK AGE: 44 YEARS,

R/O AMADALLI, TQ. KARWAR.

7. SMT. DIVYA THOKU NAIK AGE: 32 YEARS,

R/O AMADALLI, TQ. KARWAR.

8. THE DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER, KARNATAKA & GOA CIRCLE, DR. K KAMARAJ ROAD,

BANGALORE.

RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.54(1) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894 AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DTD:22-06-2010, PASSED IN LAC NO.14/2009, ON THE FILE OF THE ADDL. CIVIL JUDGE(SR.DN) KARWAR, AWARDING THE COMPENSATION OF RS. 11,500/-PER GUNTA.

IN M.F.A. NO.24907/2011:

BETWEEN

THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, SEA BIRD NAVAL BASE PROJECT, KARWAR. APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.)

AND

15

1. ANANT S/0 RAKU NAIK, R/O BHAVIKATh, TQ. ANKOLA,

1A. SMT. PARVATI W/O ANANT NAIK AGE: 73 YEARS, OCCC: HOUSEHOLD, R/O BHAVIKATTI, TQ. ANKOLA.

lB. SRI. JAYARAM 5/0 ANANT NAIK AGE: 52 YEARS,

R/O BHAVIKATPI, TQ. ANKOLA.

1C. SRI. GIRISH S/O ANANT NAIK AGE: 37 YEARS,

R/O BHAVIKAYTI, TQ. ANKOLA.

2. UDDANDA S/O RAKU NAIK SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.

2A. RAJARAM S/O UDDANDA NAIK AGE: 53 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURE, R/O BHAVIKERI, TQ. ANKOLA.

2B. SATISH S/0 UDDANDA NAIK AGE: 50 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURE, R/O BHAVIKERI, TQ. ANKOLA.

2C. JAGADISH S/O UDDANDA NAIK AGE: 48 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURE, R/0 BHAVIKERI, TQ. ANKOLA.

3. THE DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER, KARNATAKA GOA CIRCLE, BANGALO RE.

RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS PILED U/S.54(l) OP LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894 AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DTD:22-09-2008, PASSED IN LAC NO.144/2009, ON THE

J

16

FILE OF THE CIVIL JUDGE(SR.DN) KUMTA, AWARDING THE COMPENSATION OF RS.11,500/-PER GUNTA.

IN M.F.A. NO.25399/2011:

BETWEEN

THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, SEA BIRD PROJECT II,-

NAVAL BASE, KARWAR.

APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.)

AND

1. RAMACHANDRA TIMMANNA NAYAK.

1(A) RAMACHANDRA TIMMANNA NAYAK SINCE DECEASED BY HIS L.RS.

SMT. SANNAMMA

W/O.RAMACHANDRA NAYAK, 0CC: HOUSEHOLD,

R/O: BHAVIKERI, TQ: ANKOLA, DIST: NORTH KANARA.

1(B). GOPAL RAMACHANDRA NAYAK, AGE: MAJOR, 0CC: AGRICULTURE, R/O: BHAVIKERI,

TQ: ANKOLA, DIST: NORTH CANARA.

1(C) GOURISH RAMACHANDRA NAYAK, AGE: MAJOR, 0CC: AGRICULTURE, R/O: BHAVIKERI,

TQ: ANKOLA, DIST: NORTH CANARA.

1(D) GOVIND RAMACHANDRA NAYAK, AGE: MAJOR, 0CC: AGRICULTURE, R/O: BHAVIKERI,

i7

TQ: ANKOLA, N.K. DIST.

1(E) RAJAMMA D/O. RAMACHANDRA NAYAK, AGE: MAJOR, 0CC: SERVICE, R/O: BHAVIKERI,

TQ: ANKOLA, N.K. DIST.

1(F) REVATI D/O, RAMACHANDRA NAYAK, AGE: MAJOR, 0CC: SERVICE, R/O: BHAVIKERI,

TQ: ANKOLA, DIST: KARWAR.

1(G) PREMA D/0, RAMACHANDRA NAYAK, AGE: MAJOR, 0CC: SERVICE, R/O: BHAVIKERI,

TQ: ANKOLA, DIST: KARWAR.

2. TIMMANNA BOMMAYYA NAIK, R/O: BHAVIKERI, TQ: ANKOLA.

3. SATU BOMMAYYA NAIK, R/0: BHAVIKERI, TQ: ANKOLA.

4. BEERANNA BOMMAYYA NAIK, SINCE DECEASED BY HIS L.R.S.

4(A) MANGALA D/0. BEERANNA NAIK, AGE: MAJOR,

0CC: HOUSEHOLD DUTIES, R/O: ALAGERI, ANKOLA.

4(B) RAJU S/0. BEERANNA NAIK, AGE: MAJOR,

0CC: HOUSEHOLD DUTIES, R/O: ALAGERI, ANKOLA.

5. NARAYAN BOMMAYYA NAIK, R/O: BHAVIKERI, ANKOLA. r(L

18

6. MANI BOMMAYYA NAIK, R/O: BHAVIKERI, ANKOLA.

7. THE DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER, KARNATAKA GOA CIRCLE, BANGALO RE.

RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.54(1) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894 AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DTD:28-05-2010, PASSED IN LAC NO.82/2006, ON THE FILE OF THE CIVIL JUDGE(SRDN) KUMTA, AWARDING THE COMPENSATION OF RS.11,500/-PER GUNTA.

IN M.F.A. NO.25442/2011:

BETWEEN

THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER SEA BIRD PROJECT, NOW INDIAN NAVY, MINI VIDHANA SOUDHA , KARWAR. APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.)

AND

1. CHANDRAKANT S/O PANDU NAIK AGE: 55 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURIST, R/O: MUDGA, MADALLI, KARWAR.

2. THE DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER KARNATAKA & GOA CIRCLE, T-56, ASSAYALINE KAMARAJ ROAD, BANGALORE-42.

RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.54(1) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894 AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DTD:27-06-2011, PASSED IN LAC NO.05/2011, ON THE 19

FILE OF THE ADDL. CIVIL JUDGE(SR.DN) KARWAR, AWARDING THE COMPENSATION OF RS. 1 1,500/-PER GUNTA.

IN M.F.A. NO.25484/2011:

BETWEEN

THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, SEA BIRD PROJECT II,-

NAVAL BASE, KARWAR.

APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.)

AND

1. RAMANAND RAGHUPATHI SHENVI, R/O: CHENDIYA, KARWAR.

PRESENT ADDRESS:

NO. 4, GURUKRUPA LIBERTY CO.OP. HOUSING SOCIETY, LIBERTY GARDEN CROSS ROAD, NO.4, MALAD (WEST),

BOMBAY 400 064.

-

2. THE DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER, KARNATAKA GOA CIRCLE, BANGALORE.

RESPONDENTS

THIS M.F.A. IS FILED U/SEC. 54(1) OF THE LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894, PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD PASSED BY THE REFERENCE COURT I.E., ADDL. CIVIL JUDGE (SR.DN.) KUMTA, IN L.A.C. NO. 280/1994 ON THE FILE OF THE ADDL. CIVIL JUDGE (SR.DN) KARWAR, AWARDING THE COMPENSATION OF RS.11,500/-PER GUNTA. 20

IN M.F.A. NO.25490/2011:

BETWEEN

THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, PROJECT SEA BIRD, KARWAR DIST. APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.)

AND

1. U. F. M. GOVID S/0 KHEMI GOUDA AGE: MAJOR, RYOT R/O KODAR, NOWT AT SEA BIRD COLONY, TODUR, KARWAR DIST.

2. THE DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER, KARNATAKA & GOA CIRCLE, BANGALORE-42.

RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS FILED U/SEC. 54(1) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT 1894, AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED:15.12.2010 PASSED IN L.A.C. NO.114/2010, ON THE FILE OF THE ADDITIONAL CIVIL JUDGE (SR.DN.), KARWAR, AWARDING THE COMPENSATION OF RS.11,500/- PER GUNTA.

IN M.F.A. NO.25591/2011:

BETWEEN

THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, SEA BIRD PROJECT NAVAL BASE, KARWAR.

APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.) j

21

AND

1. SRI YOKU NAGU GOUDA R/O:BADAGERI BHAVIEKRI, TQ:ANKOLA.

2. SRI BECCHU NINGU GOUDA R/O:BADAGERI BHAVIEKRI, TQ:ANKOLA.

3. SRI KAMANNA S/O DEVU GOUDA R/O:BADAGERI BHAVIEKRI, TQ:ANKOLA.

4, SRI CHANNA DEVU GOUDA, R/O:BADAGERI BHAVIEKRI, TQ :ANKOLA.

5. SRI TAKKU DEVI GOUDA, R/O:BADAGERI BHAVIEKRI, TQ:ANKOLA.

6. THE DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER, KARNATAKA GOA CIRCLE, BANGALORE. ... RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS FILED U/SEC. 54(1) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT 1894, AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED:30.03.2009 PASSED IN L.A.C. NO.192/2006, ON THE FILE OF THE CIVIL JUDGE (SR.DN.), KUMTA, AWARDING THE COMPENSATION OF RS.11,500/- PER GUNTA.

IN M.F.A. NO.25719/2011:

BETWEEN

THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, SEA BIRD PROJECT, KARWAR. ... APPELLANT (BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.) 22

AND

1. BABU SINDYA GUNAGI AGE: MAJOR, L.R OF SINDHYA SOMU GUNAGI RIO. GUNAGIWADA, ARGA, KARWAR.

2. BHASKAR SINDYA GUNAGI AGE: MAJOR,

R/O. ARGA, KARWAR.

3. MIRYA SINDYA GUNAGI AGE: MAJOR,

RIO. ARGA, KARWAR.

4. RUKMANGADA SINDYA GUNAGI AGE: MAJOR,

R/O. ARGA, KARWAR.

5. GEETA SADANAND GUNAGI.

6. HEMILA S/O. SINDYA GUNAGI AGE: MAJOR,

R/O. ARGA, KARWAR.

7. D.E.O. KAMARAJ ROAD, BANGALORE. ... RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.54(1) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894 AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DTD:24-06-2011, PASSED IN LAC NO.19/2007, ON THE FILE OF THE II-ADDL. CIVIL JUDGE(SR.DN) KARWAR, AWARDING THE COMPENSATION OF RS.11,500/-PER GUNTA.

IN M.F.A. NO.20367/20 12:

BETWEEN

THE LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, SEA BIRD PROJECT,

23

NOW INDIAN NEW,

MINI VIDHANA SOUDHA, M.G.ROAD, KARWAR.

APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.)

AND

LAKSHU VASU GOUDA,

SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.

1. SMT. GOURI KOM LAKSHU GOUDA, AGE: 68 YEARS, 0CC: RYOT, R,'O: ANIGADDA, TQ: ANKOLA.

2. GANAPATHI S/O. LAKSHU GOUDA, AGE: 48 YEARS, RYOT, R/O: ANGIGADDA, TQ: ANKOLA.

3. HADU S/O. LAKSHU GOUDA, AGE: 40 YEARS, RYOT, R/O: ANIGADDA, TQ: ANKOLA.

4. THE DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER, K & G CIRCLE, T-56, ASSAYALINE, KAMRAJ ROAD, BANGALORE. RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.54(1) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894, AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DTD:01.04.2011, PASSED IN LAC NO.1/2010, ON THE FILE OF THE ADDL. CIVIL JUDGE(SR.DN.), KARWAR, AWARDING COMPENSATION OF RS, 11,500/- PER GUNTA.

IN M.F.A. NO.20386/2012:

BETWEEN

THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, PROJECT SEA BIRD,

NAVAL BASE, KARWAR.

APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.)

AND

MOTAMOTA THEKU NAIK

SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS

I. SMT. TALASI W/O. MOTA NAIK AGE: 62 YEARS.

0CC: HOUSEHOLD WORK

RIO. OPP. MAHASATI KALYAN MANTAP, KAJUBAG, KARWAR.

2. SMT. SUMANA D/O. MOTA NAIK W/O. RAMAKANT NAIK

AGE: 42 YEARS.

0CC: HOUSEHOLD WORK

R/O. OPP. MAHASATI KALYAN MANTAP, KAJUBAG, KARWAR.

3. SMT. PRABRAVATI D/O. MOTA NAIK W/O. THAKU NAIK

0CC: HOUSEHOLD WORK

R/O. OPP. MAHASATI KALYAN MANTAP, KAJUBAG, KARWAR.

4. KRISHNA THAKU NAIK RIO. ALIGADDA, CHENDIYA TQ: KARWAR.

5. SHANTARAM THEKU NAIK RIO. ALIGADDA, CHENDIYA TQ: KARWAR.

6. DAMODAR THEKU NAIK R/O. ALIGADDA, CHENDIYA 25

TQ: KARWAR,

7. NAVARAJ THEKU NAIK R/0. ALIGADDA, CHENDIYA TQ: KARWAR.

THAKU BUDDU NAIK

SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS

8. JAYA S/O. THANKU NAIK AGE: 65 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURE, R/0. KALISHITI'A, BAAD, KARWAR.

9. ANAND S/O. ACHYUT NAIK AGE: 30 YEARS, 0CC: GOVT. SERVICE, R/O. KALISHI'ITA, BAAD, KARWAR.

10. DiVfl'ARAM S/0. THAKU NAIK AGE: 44 YEARS,

0CC: BUS CONDUCTOR,

R/0. KALISHITTA, BAAD, KARWAR.

11. HEMANAND S/0. THANKU NAIK AGE: 35 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURE, RIO. TODUR COLONY,

KARWAR.

12. SMT. VEKAMMA KOM VITTAL NAIK AGE: 58 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURE, R/0. KALISHITTA, BAAD, KARWAR.

13. SMT. MEERA @ KALPANA W/0. SHIVANAND NAIK

AGE: 55 YEARS,

R/0. KOMARPATWADA, KODIBAG, KARWAR.

fr&

26

14. SMT. MEGHABAI ( GUNAVANTI W/0. RATNAKAR NAIK

AGE: 52 YEARS,

R/O. NEAR GINDI TEMPLE, KODIBAG, KARWAR.

15. SMT. LEELA SYAMALA SARVO'Il'AM NAIK AGE: 42 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURE, R/O. HARAWADA, TQ: ANKOLA, KARWAR,

16. SMT. TOMARI @. ROOPA W/O. HARISCHANDRA NAIK R/AT. CIVIL HOSPITAL QUARTERS, M.G. ROAD, KARWAR.

17. THE DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER, KARNATAKA & GOA CIRCLE, BANGALORE-42.

RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.54(1) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894, AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DTD:28.02.2008, PASSED IN LAC NO.133/1991, ON THE FILE OF THE ADDL. CIVIL JUDGE(SR.DN.), KARWAR, AWARDING COMPENSATION OF RS.1 1,500/- PER GUNTA.

IN M.F.A. NO.20390/2012:

BETWEEN

THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, SEA BIRD PROJECT,

NOW INDIAN NEW,

MINI VIDHANA SOUDHA, M.G.ROAD, KARWAR.

APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.) 27

AND

I. BOLA TIMMA GOUDA AGE: MAJOR, RYOL, R/O. KODAR NOW AT SEA BIRD COLONY, TODUR, TQ : KARWAR.

2. THE DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER K & G CIRCLE, T-56, ASSAYALINC, KAMARAJ ROAD, BANGALORE. RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.54(1) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894, AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DTD:01.04.2011, PASSED IN LAC NO.2/2010, ON THE FILE OF THE ADDL. CIVIL JUDGE(SR.DN.), KARWAR, AWARDING COMPENSATION OF RS.11,500/- PER GUNTA.

IN M.F.A. NO.20412/2012:

BETWEEN

THE SPECIAL LAND ACUQISITION OFFICER, SEA BIRD PROJECT,

NAVAL BASE, KARWAR.

APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.)

AND

• BANTA RAM GOUDA MINOR, REPTED. BY FATHER RAMA BANTA GOUDA,

R/O. BADAGERI, BHAVIKAERI, ANKOLA.

28

RAKU DEVA GOUDA,

R/O. BADAGERI,

BHAVIKERI, ANKOLA.

SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS

2. DEVU RAKU GOUDA AGE: 60 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURE RIO. BADAGERI, BHAVIKERI, ANKOLA.

BUDDU DEVU GOUDA

R/0. BADAGERI, BHAVIKERI, ANKOLA.

SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS

3. SURESH BUDDU GOUDA AGE: 30 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURE R/0. BADAGERI, BHAVIKERI, ANKOLA.

4. KESHAV SANNAKUS GOUDA R/0. BADAGERI, BHAVIKERI, ANKOLA.

5. TULASU HEDDU GOUDA R/O. BADAGERI, BHAVIKERI, ANKOLA.

6. THE DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER, KARNATAKA & GOA CIRCLE, BANGALORE-42.

RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.54(l) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894, AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DTD:29.11.2008, PASSED IN LAC NO.142/2006, ON THE FILE OF THE CIVIL JUDGE(SR.DN.), KUMTA, AWARDING COMPENSATION OF RS.11,500/- PER GUNTA. frt

29

IN M.F.A. NO.20413/2012:

BETWEEN

THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, SEA BIRD PROJECT,

NAVAL BASE, KARWAR.

APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A,)

AND

HANUMANT S/O. GOVIND NAIK SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.

1. SARASWATT W/O. NAGAPPA NAIK AGE: 70 YEARS, 0CC: HOUSEHOLD R/0. SAKALBENA, AVERSA, TQ: ANKOLA, DIST: UTI'AR KANNADA.

2. NINGAPPA 5/0. HANUMANT NAIK AGE: 73 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURE, R/O. SAKALBENA, AVERSA, TQ: ANKOLA, DIST: UTTAR KANNADA.

3. PUNDALIK S/0. HANUMANT NAIK AGE: 68 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURE, R/O. SAKALBENA, AVERSA, TQ: ANKOLA, DIST: UTT'AR KANNADA.

4. SHRIKANT S/O. HANUMANT NAIK AGE: 57 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURE, R/O. SAKALBENA, AVERSA, TQ: ANKOLA, DIST: UTI'AR KANNADA.

5. MAHADEVI W/0. SUKRU NAIK, U.F.M. AGE: 55 YEARS, 0CC: HOUSEHOLD R/O. SAKALBENA, AVERSA, 30

TQ: ANKOLA, DIST: U11'AR KANNADA.

6. SUBHADRI SANDHYA D/O. HANUMANT NAIK

AGE: 53 YEARS, 0CC: HOUSEHOLD RIO. SAKALBENA, AVERSA, TQ: ANKOLA, DIST: UTI'AR KANNADA.

7. ANANDI D/O. HANUMANT NAIK AGE: 60 YEARS, 0CC: HOUSEHOLD R/O. SAKALBENA, AVERSA, TQ: ANKOLA, DIST: UTTAR KANNADA.

8. THE DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER, KARNATAKA @ GOA CIRCLE, BANGALORE-42.

RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.54(1) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894, AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DTD:16.09.2009, PASSED IN LAC NO.234/2006, ON THE FILE OF THE CIVIL JUDGE(SR.DN.), KUMTA AWARDING COMPENSATION OF RS.11,500/- PER GUNTA.

IN M.F.A. NO.20566/2012:

BETWEEN

THE SPECIAL LAND ACUQISITION OFFICER SEA BIRD PROJECT, NOW INDIAN NAVY, MINI VIDHANA SOUDHA, KARWAR. APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.)

AND

1. PREMA @ PREMABAI CAHNDRAKANT NAIK AGE: 45 YEARS, CCC: AGRICULTURE, 31

R/O. MUDAGA, AMADALLI, KARWAR.

2. THE DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER, KARNATAKA & GOA CIRCLE, T-56, ASSAYALINGA KUMARAJ ROAD, BANGALORE-42. RESPONDENTS ...

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.54(1) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894, AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DTD:27.06.2011, PASSED IN LAC NO.11/2011, ON THE FILE OF THE ADDL. CIVIL JUDGE(SR.DN.), KARWAR, AWARDING COMPENSATION OF RS.1 1,500/- PER GUNTA.

IN M.F.A. NO.20569/2012:

BETWEEN

THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, SEA BIRD PROJECT,

NAVAL BASE, KARWAR. ... APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.)

AND

1. MANGALDAS S/O. SUBRAY KAMAT AGE: MAJOR, 0CC: RYOT, R/O. AVERSA, TQ: ANKOLA.

2. THE DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER, KARNATAKA & GOA CIRCLE, BANGALORE-42.

RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.54(1) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894, AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DTD:30.06.201 1, PASSED IN LAC NO.4/2011, ON THE FILE OF THE SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE, KUMTA, AWARDING COMPENSATION OF RS.20,770/- PER GUNTA. 32

IN M.F.A. NO.21219/2012:

BETWEEN

THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, SEA BIRD, NAVAL BASE, KARWAR,

APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.)

AND

1. PREMA RAMA GUNAGI, AGE: MAJOR,

R/O. KODAR VILLAGE,

KARWAR, TQ: DIST: UTTAR KANNADA.

2. THE DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER, KARNATAKA & GOA CIRCLE, K. KAMRAJ ROAD, BANGALORE-42. RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA FILED U/S.54(1) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894, AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DTD:30.10.2006, PASSED IN LAC NO.261/1994, ON THE FILE OF THE ADDL. CIVIL JUDGE(SR.DN.), KARWAR, AWARDING COMPENSATION OF RS. 11,500/- PER GUNTA.

IN M.F.A. NO.22376/20 12:

BETWEEN

1. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA, BY ITS PRINCIPAL SECRETARY, REVENUE DEPARTMENT,

M.S. BUILDING, BANGALORE. frtl

2. THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER, SEA BIRD PROJECT, NAVAL BASE, KARWAR,

APPELLANTS

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.)

AND

L RUPUKUSLUGOUDA SINCE DECEASED BY LRS.

1A. RAMA S/0. RUPU GOUDA AGE: 58 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURE, R/O. BADAGARI, BHAVIKERI, ANKOLA.

lB. NAGI D/O. RUPU GOUDA SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.

RENUKA KOM KESHAVA GOUDA, AGE: 51 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURE, R/O. BHAVIKERI, ANKOLA.

2. NAGU S/O. KASLU GOUDA SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.

2A. TOKU NAGU GOUDA, AGE: 53 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURE, R/0. BADAGERI, BHAVIKERI, ANKOLA.

2B. POKKA NAGU GOUDA AGE: 51 YEARS,

0CC: AGRICULTURE,

R/O. BADAGERI, BHAVIKERI, ANKOLA.

2C. SAVITHRI W/0. MANKALU GOUDA AGE: 38 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURE, 34

R/O. BADAGERI, BHAVIKERI, ANKOLA.

3. THE DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER, KARNATAKA GOA CIRCLE, BANGALORE.

RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.54(1) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894, AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DTD:16.12.2008, PASSED IN LAC NO.28/2006, ON THE FILE OF THE CIVIL JUDGE(SR.DN.), KUMTA, AWARDING COMPENSATION OF RS.11,500/- PER GUNTA.

IN M.F.A. NO.22430/2012:

BETWEEN

I. STATE OF KARNATAKA BY ITS SECRETARY TO

THE REVENUE DEPARTMENT, M.S.BUILDING, BANGALORE.

2. THE SPECIAL LAND AQUISITION OFFICER, AND KONKAN RAILWAY CORPORATION LTD., KARWAR.

APPELLANTS

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.)

AND

1. BUDDU SOMEBADDU SOME GOUDA AGE: 51 YRS, R/O BADAGERI, POST: BHAVIKERI, TQ: ANKOLA.

SOMA SOMU GOUDA

SINCE DECEASED HIS LRS

2. SANNU W/O SOMA GOUDA AGE: 60 YRS,

35

0CC: HOUSEHOLD DUITES, R/O BADAGERI, TQ: ANKOLA.

RAMA S/O SOMA GOUDA

SINCE DECEASED HIS LRS.

3. SANMAGU W/O RAMA GOUDA AGE: 39 YRS,

0CC: HOUSEHOLD DUITES, R/O BADAGERI, TQ: ANKOLA.

4. UMESH S/0 RAMA GOUDA AGE: 20 YRS,

0CC: HOUSEHOLD DUTIES, R/O BADAGERI, TQ: ANKOLA.

5. KUSUMA W/O RAJU GOUDA AGE: 22 YRS,

0CC: HOUSEHOLD DUTIES, R/0 BADAGERI, TQ: ANKOLA.

6. HALAKKI S/0 SOMA GOUDA AGE: 40 YRS, 0CC: AGRICULTURIST R/0 BADAGERI, TQ: ANKOLA.

7. SHIVAKANT S/O SOMA GOUDA AGE: 35 YRS, 0CC: AGRICULTURIST R/0 BADAGERI, TQ: ANKOLA.

8. GULABI W/0 DEVU GOUDA AGE: 42 YRS, 0CC: HOUSEHOLD DUTIES, R/O BADAGERI, TQ: ANKOLA.

9. AYAMMA W/O SUKRU GOUDA AGE: 36 YRS, 0CC: HOUSEHOLD DUTIES, R/O BADAGERI, TQ: ANKOLA.

RAKU SOMU GOUDA

SINCE DECESED BY HIS LRS 36

10, HONNAPPA RAKU GOUDA, AGE: 35 YRS,

R/O BHAVIKERI, TQ: ANKOLA.

11. BUDDURAKUGOUDA AGE: 32 YRS,

R/O BHAVIKERI, TQ: ANKOLA.

12. DEVU SUKRU GOUDA AGE: 38 YRS, R/O BADAGERI POST: BHAVIKERI, TQ: ANKOLA.

HONNA SUKRU GOUDA

SINCE DECEASED HIS LRS

13. MANGALA W/O HONNA GOUDA AGE: 30 YRS, R/O BHAVIKERI, TQ: ANKOLA.

14. DEEPIKA HONNA GOUDA AGE: 18 YRS, R/O BHAVIKERI TQ: ANKOLA.

15. THE DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER, KARNATAKA & GOA CIRCLE, BANGALORE. ... RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.54(1) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894, AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DTD:05.04.2010, PASSED IN LAC NO.30/2006, ON THE FILE OF THE CIVIL JUDGE (SR.DN.) KUMTA, AWARDING COMPENSATION OF RS.11,500/- PER GUNTA.

IN M.F.A. NO.22431/2012:

BETWEEN

1. STATE OF KARNATAKA REPTD. BY ITS PRL. SECRETARY, REVENUE DEPARTMENT, VIDHANA SOUDHA, BANGALORE. 37

2. THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISiTION OFFICER, PROJECT SEA BIRD, NAVAL BASE, MINI VIDHANA SOUDHA, KARWAR. APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K, VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.)

AND

1. SMT. UMBAI RENUKA NAIK, R/O AMADALLI, VILLAGE, KARWAR.

2. KRISHNA RENUKA NAIK R/O AMADALLI VILLAGE, KARWAR.

3. VISHNU RENUKA NAIK, R/O AMADALLI VILLAGE, KARWAR.

4. GANAPATI RENUKA NAIK R/O AMADALLI VILLAGE, KARWAR.

5. THE DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER, KARNATAKA & GOA CIRCLE, BANGALORE-560 042.

RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.54(1) OF LAND ACQUISI TION

ACT, 1894, AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD

DTD:07.07.2011, PASSED IN LAC NO.119/2010 , ON THE

FILE OF THE ADDL. CIVIL JUDGE (SR.DN. ), KARWAR,

AWARDING COMPENSATION OF RS.1 1,500/- PER GUNTA.

38

IN M.F.A. NO.22462/2012:

BETWEEN

I. STATE OF KARNATAKA BY ITS SECRETARY TO THE REVENUE DEPARTMENT, M.S. BUILDING, BAN GALORE,

2. THE SPECIAL LAND ACUQISITION OFFICER, SEA BIRD PROJECT, NAVAL BASE, KARWAR.

APPELLANTS

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.)

AND

I. SHIVA MANKALU GOUDA R/O. BADAGERI, BHAVIKERI, TQ: ANKOLA.

2. TIMMA MANKALU GOUDA R/O. BADAGERI, BHAVIKAERI, TQ: ANKOLA.

KUTNA MANKALU GOUDA

R/O. BADAGERI,

BHAVIKERI, TQ. ANKOLA. SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.,

3. SHIVA S/0. MANKALU GOUDA AGE: 60 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURE, R/O. BADAGERI, BHAVIKAERI, TQ: ANKOLA.

4. TIMMA S/O. MANKALU GOUDA AGE: 55 YEARS,

R/O. BADAGERI, ALAGERI,

frL

39

TQ: ANKOLA.

BUDDU GIDDA GOUDA

AGE. 55 YEARS, R/O.BADAOERI, ALAGERI, TQ. ANKOLA. SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.

5. SMT. DOLLI W/O. BUDDU GOUDA AGE: 45 YEARS, 0CC: HOUSEHOLD WORK, R/O. NEAR PRIMARY SCHOOL, BADAGERI, BHAVIKERI, TQ: ANKOLA.

6. SMT. SUMITRA D/O. BUDDU GOUDA AGE: 25 YEARS,

0CC: HOUSEHOLD WORK, R/O. NEAR PRIMARY SCHOOL, BADAGERI, BHAVIKERI, TQ: ANKOLA.

7. BEERA S/O. BUDDU GOUDA AGE: 23 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURE, R/0. NEAR PRIMARY SCHOOL, BADAGERI, BHAVIKERI, TQ: ANKOLA.

8. VINAYAK S/O. BUDDU GOUDA AGE: 20 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURE, R/O. NEAR PRIMARY SCHOOL, BADAGERI, BHAVIKERI, TQ: ANKOLA.

9. RAMESH Sb. BUDDU GOUDA AGE: 18 YEARS, 0CC: AGRICULTURE, R/O. NEAR PRIMARY SCHOOL, BADAGERI, BHAVIKERI, TQ: ANKOLA.

10. GOVIND GIDDA GOUDA R/O. BADAGERI,

BHAVIKERI, TQ: ANKOLA. 40

11. A'U GIDDA GOUDA RIO. BADAGERI,

BHAVIKERI, TQ: ANKOLA.

12. THE DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER, KARNATAKA & GOA CIRCLE, BANGALORE.

RESPONDENTS

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S.54(1) OF LAND ACQUISITION ACT, 1894, AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DTD:16.09.2009, PASSED IN LAC NO.183/2006, ON THE FILE OF THE CIVIL JUDGE (SR.DN.) KUMTA, AWARDING COMPENSATION OF RS.1 1,500/- PER GUNTA.

IN M.F.A. NO.22889/2009:

BETWEEN

THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER PROJECT SEA BIRD, NAVAL BASE, KARWAR.

APPELLANT

(BY SMT. K. VIDYAVATI, A.G.A.)

AND

1. SIDDA JANGA GOUDA RYOT, SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LR.

1A. UMAKANT SIDDA GOUDA, R/O AMADALLI, DIST:KARWAR. SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LR.

a) SIDDA JANGA GOUDA RYOT R/O. AMADALLI,

KARWAR TALUK & DIST.

2. SANNE W/O THIMA GOUDA 41

SINCE DECEASED BY HER LRS.

2A. KRISHNA TAMSAKE GOUDA AGED:60 YRS, RIO MUDALMAKKI, BINGAGA.

2B. VASU TAMSHAKA GOUDA AGE:45 YRS, R/O MUDALMAKKI, BINGAGA.

2C. SMT. HOLI W/O NARAYAN GOUDA AGE:40 YRS, R/O MUDALMAKKI, BINGAGA.

3. SOMU KUSLA GOUDA SINCE DECEASED BY HIS LRS.

3A. RAMACHANDRA 5/0 SOMA GOUDA AGED:38 YRS, R/O SAKALBENA, AVERSA, TQ:ANKOLA, DIST:KARWAR.

3B. THAKU 5/0 SOMA GOUDA AGED:30 YRS, RYOT,

R/O SAKALBENA, AVERSA, TQ:ANKOLA, DIST:KARWAR.

3C. JAIWANT S/O SOMA GOUDA AGED:28 YRS, RYOT,

R/O SAKALBENA, AVERSA, TQ:ANKOLA, DIST:KARWAR.

3D. DEVI D/O SOMA GOUDA AGED:24 YRS, RYOT,

R/O SAKALBENA, AVERSA, TQ:ANKOLA, DIST:KARWAR.

3E. SAROJINI D/O SOMA GOUDA AGED:24 YRS, RYOT,

R/O SAKALBENA, AVERSA, 42

TQ:ANKOLA, DIST:KARWAR.

3F. GANDHARI D/O SOMAGOUDA AGED: 18 YRS, RYOT,

R/O SAKALBENA, AVERSA, TQ:ANKOLA, DIST:KARWAR.

3G. SMT. PREETI W/O SOMA GOUDA AGED:65 YRS, RYOT,

R/O SAKALBENA, AVERSA, TQ:ANKOLA, DIST:KARWAR,

3H. SMT. PARVATI W/O ASHOK GOUDA AGE:MAJOR, RYOT,

R/O TODUR COLONY,

TQ. & DIST:KARWAR.

31, DOLLA S/O KHUSLU GOUDA AGED:60 YRS,

R/O TODUR COLONY,

DI ST: KARWAR.

3J. SEETARAM S/O KHUSLU GOUDA AGED:55 YRS,

R/O TODUR COLONY,

DIST:KARWAR.

4. MOTA 5/0 KRISHNA GOUDA R/O MUDAGA, AMADALLI, DIST:KARWAR.

5. THE DEFENCE ESTATE OFFICER, KARNATAKA & GOA CIRCLE, BANGALORE.

RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI SIDDAPPA S. SAJJAN, ADV. FOR R4; SRI B. PAPEGOUDA, ADV. FOR R5; R2(A-C) & R3(A-J) ARE SERVED)

43

c

THIS MFA IS FILED U/S. 54(1) OF THE LAND ACQUISITION ACT 1894, AGAINST THE JUDGEMENT AND AWARD DATED:23-03-2007, PASSED IN L.A.C, NO.16/ 1995 ON THE FILE OF THE ADDITIONAL CIVIL JUDGE (SR.DN.), AT KARWAR. AWARDING COMPENSATION OF RS. 11,500 /-

PER GUNTA.

THESE APPEALS COMING ON FOR ADMISSION THIS DAY, THE COURT DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

JUDGMENT

Common questions of law and fact arise for decision making, and therefore, these appeals are clubbed togeth er and disposed of by this order.

2. Learned Government Advocate submits that a Division Bench of this Court in M.F.A. NO.20344/20 10 and connected appeals by order dated 31.05.2010, confirmed the market value of the land acquired for Sea Bird Project, at Rs. 11,500/- per gunta. In that view of the matter, these appeals do not survive for consideration. Appeals are accordingly dismissed.

JUDGE

hnm/